December 5-11, 2005
| December 9, 2005: | Alabama-Huntsville 4 at Princeton 2 | RECAP | BOX | |
| Robert Morris 0 at Niagara 1 | EAGLE RECAP | COLONIAL RECAP | BOX | |
| Lake Superior State 2 at Bemidji State 1 | RECAP | BOX | ||
| Merrimack 2 at Wayne State 3 | RECAP | BOX | ||
| December 10, 2005: | Alabama-Huntsville 0 at Princeton 4 | RECAP | BOX | |
| Robert Morris 0 at Niagara 3 | EAGLE RECAP | COLONIAL RECAP | BOX | |
| Lake Superior State 2 at Bemidji State 2 | RECAP | BOX | ||
| Merrimack 5 at Wayne State 6 OT | RECAP | BOX | ||
